The $40 Billion Wellness Apocalypse Is Coming

Read on Substack

And it may create the biggest opportunity in wellness.

91% of Boutique Fitness Studios Aren’t Profitable.

Read that again.

Because I did. Three times.

Then I looked out my car window and drove past another pilates studio opening in LA. Another reformer. Another membership. Another lease.

I came across that stat while diligencing the hottest deal in wellness right now. I can't say more now, but will soon (obviously)…and honestly? Even obsessing about this deal — the stat stopped me cold.

Because it creates a paradox. Wellness is booming. Consumers are spending more on fitness, recovery, longevity, supplements, wearables, and preventative health than ever before.

So…if demand is growing, why are so few operators making money?

I think the answer has almost nothing to do with fitness.

For anyone unfamiliar, a four-wall business is exactly what it sounds like: gyms, studios, clinics, salons, stores. Places where actual humans leave their homes and interact with other actual humans.

(Increasingly rare behavior, if we’re being honest.)

The more I sat with that 91% stat, the more I realized we’ve been telling ourselves the wrong story. Most people look at boutique fitness and conclude there’s too much competition.

I don’t think that’s quite right. I think we’ve been analyzing these businesses as fitness businesses.

What if they’re not fitness businesses at all?

What if they’re community businesses?

What if consumers aren’t looking for another workout…they’re looking for somewhere to belong?

Because while everyone was talking about boutique fitness, something else was happening at the same time. We lost our third places. The spaces that existed between work and home. Coffee shops. Community centers. Bookstores. Malls. The places where people accidentally spent time together.

For years, we convinced ourselves boutique fitness had become that. But when was the last time you actually hung out at a Pilates studio? Not worked out. Hung out.

When was the last time you sat there for two hours after class talking to friends?

When was the last time you met someone new and ended up spending the rest of your afternoon together?

Most studios aren’t third spaces. They’re transactional spaces. You show up. You sweat. You leave.

And yet consumers are craving connection more than ever. People are lonely. Really lonely. We’re spending our days staring at screens, sending voice notes, texting friends we haven’t actually seen in months, and Googling things like “how do I make friends as an adult?”

At the exact same time, wellness has become one of the defining consumer categories of our generation. People are drinking less. Prioritizing longevity, strength, recovery, sleep, prevention.

And then there’s the GLP-1 effect. The more I study GLP-1s, the more convinced I become that their impact extends far beyond food. Millions of people are reorganizing their social lives around consuming less — less alcohol, less snacking, less mindless eating.

Historically, an enormous amount of social interaction happened around food and drinks. Birthday dinners. Happy hours. Bottomless brunches. Wine nights. The restaurant became the default third place for adults.

But what happens when consumers still want connection, yet no longer want a second margarita and shared nachos? Where do they go?

That’s the question I can’t stop thinking about…

Because I don’t think we’re watching the future of fitness unfold.

I think we’re watching the next generation of third spaces emerge in real time. And the company we’re diligencing right now made me realize something important.

The winners aren’t going to build more studios. They’re not going to win because they have more locations, or because they invented some slightly different way to squat, stretch, sweat, jump, pedal, or plank. They’re going to win because they understand something most of the industry forgot.

People don’t actually want fitness. They want connection. Fitness just happens to be the excuse.

And if 91% of studios aren’t profitable, but demand for connection has never been higher — we’re on the verge of a massive reset.

Some concepts will disappear.

Some leases won’t get renewed.

Some brands consumers assumed would be around forever won’t be.

But on the other side of that shakeout, I think we’re going to see something much more interesting emerge. A completely different version of the third place.

One built around wellness. One built around belonging. One built for how people actually live now.

And that’s exactly what I’m betting on.

Behind the paywall, let’s talk about what the next generation of third spaces actually looks like, why most boutique fitness concepts are structurally broken, and the five characteristics every winning four-wall business will need over the next decade.

The Extinction Event Is Already Happening

Let me tell you what the data actually says, and why I think the shakeout hits harder and faster than even the pessimists are projecting.

The pandemic gave boutique fitness a false resurrection. Pent-up demand flooded back. Studios that should have closed got a second life. Investors who should have known better poured money into formats that were already broken pre-2020.

We overbuilt. We overfranchised. We over-promised.

The bill is coming due.

The three reasons most studios fail (and none of them are the workout):

1. They sold an aesthetic, not an outcome. The lighting. The playlist. The branded towel. That was the product. And consumers are done paying $45 a class for ambiance when a $15/month app delivers a better result. The studios that survive own a transformation, not just a vibe. Progress tracking, coaching continuity, programming that actually evolves with you. If you can’t answer “what did this member achieve in 90 days,” you don’t have retention. You have a revolving door.

2. They confused a following for a community. Having a waitlist isn’t community. Having a good playlist isn’t community. Posting aesthetic content that gets saved isn’t community. Community is what happens when a member misses two weeks and three people notice. It’s the group chat that exists without the studio’s involvement. It’s the friendships that outlast the membership. Most studios never built that. They built a brand. Brands don’t retain. Belonging does.

3. They signed leases like they were printing money. Real estate is where four-wall businesses go to die. Oversized footprints. Peak retail rents. $800K buildouts before a single class sold. The studios with staying power are ruthlessly disciplined on square footage — less space, more margin, more flexibility to weather the inevitable bad months. This is the least sexy thing I will say in this entire post. It is also the most important. Lease discipline isn’t an operational detail. It’s a survival strategy.

The category quietly replacing all of it

Here’s what I’m actually watching: the businesses taking share from traditional boutique fitness aren’t other fitness studios. They’re hybrid spaces. Community-first concepts where the workout is almost secondary to the belonging.

Picture a space that looks more like a members’ club than a gym. Where the lobby is designed to make you stay, not leave. Where there’s a coffee bar, a couch, a reason to linger. Where the programming is built around a specific person — a new mom, a woman in perimenopause, someone rebuilding their health after a diagnosis — not a modality. Where the front desk knows your name because knowing your name is part of the business model.

The workout is the excuse. The community is the product. The identity is the moat.

These spaces aren’t organized around what you do when you’re there. They’re organized around who you are and what you’re going through. That’s a fundamentally different value proposition than “we have reformers and good lighting.”

This is where GLP-1s come in — and not in the way most people are talking about.

The real downstream effect isn’t smaller class sizes or reformulated protein bars. It’s behavioral. People on these medications are reorganizing their entire social architecture. Fewer dinners out. Fewer drinks. More intentional about how and where they spend time. They still want connection. They still want ritual. They just want it in a different container.

The wellness space that becomes that container wins the next decade.

What I look for in every four-wall investment now:

Member tenure over new member acquisition rate. Community behavior that exists off-platform. Outcome ownership — can the member take their progress data with them? Real estate discipline. And one question I always ask founders: what happens when a member’s life gets hard? Do they cancel, or do they show up more? The answer tells you everything.

The four-wall I’m evaluating checks every one of these boxes. I’ll share more when I can.

But the framework above is how I’m thinking about every four-wall bet right now — and honestly, what every consumer should be thinking about before they sign another year of unlimited classes somewhere that might not exist in 18 months.

The next era of this space is going to be better than what we built.

It just requires most of what we built to fail first.

All the best,

Rachel & WGV Team